I checked what you were suggesting: both the controllers can communicate without any problem to all the nodes.

Today I tried multiple times the dynamics of takeover between the primary and the backup controller and I noticed that
the first scontrol takeover works perfectly: the backup controller become the controller in charge and all the sinfo and
squeue requests are satisfied.

Everything works fine also when the primary controller is back online: again the jobs continue to run fine and the
output of the commands sinfo and squeue are fine.

The very strange behavior arrives when I test the takeover mechanism for the second consecutive time with the
command scontrol takeover always from the backup controller: in this case everything seems fine at the beginning from
the log file: all the information about the resources and the jobs are recovered and the backup controller declare to
be the current primary controller but then it gets completely crazy. Here are the few lines in the log file before the
madness starts:

[2024-03-26T15:12:17.664] Running as primary controller
[2024-03-26T15:12:17.664] debug:  Heartbeat thread started, beating every 5 seconds.
[2024-03-26T15:12:17.712] debug:  No feds to retrieve from state
[2024-03-26T15:12:17.796] Resuming operation with already established listening sockets
[2024-03-26T15:12:17.797] error: slurm_accept_msg_conn poll: Bad address
[2024-03-26T15:12:17.797] error: slurm_accept_msg_conn poll: Bad address
[2024-03-26T15:12:17.797] error: slurm_accept_msg_conn poll: Bad address

From this moment on, the error message is the only thing that is continuously written on the log file and the controller
is unreachable by all the nodes: the only way to recover the backup controller is to restart the service.

What might be the cause?


On 25/03/24 22:59, Brian Andrus via slurm-users wrote:

I would hazard to guess that the DNS is not working fully from or for the nodes themselves.

Validate that you can ping the nodes by name from the backup controller. Also verify they are named what the dns says they are.  And validate you can ping the backup controller from the nodes by the name it has in the slurm.conf file.

Also, a quick way to do the failover check is to run (from the backup controller): scontrol takeover

Brian Andrus

On 3/25/2024 1:39 PM, Miriam Olmi wrote:
Hi Brian,

Thanks for replying.

In my first message I forgot to specify that the primary and the backup controller have a shared filesystem mounted.

The SaveStateLocation points to a directory placed on the shared filesystem so both the primary and the backup controller are really reading/writing the very same files.

Any other ideas?

Thanks again,
Miriam


Il 25 marzo 2024 19:23:23 CET, Brian Andrus via slurm-users <slurm-users@lists.schedmd.com> ha scritto:
Quick correction, it is SaveStateLocation not SlurmSaveState.

Brian Andrus

On 3/25/2024 8:11 AM, Miriam Olmi via slurm-users wrote:

Dear all,

I am having trouble finalizing the configuration of the backup controller for my slurm cluster.

In principle, if no job is running everything seems fine: both the slurmctld services on the
primary and the backup controller are running and if I stop the service on the primary controller
after 10s more or less (SlurmctldTimeout = 10 sec) the backup controller takes over.

Also, if I run the sinfo or squeue command during the 10s of inactivity, the shell stay pending
but it recover perfectly after the time needed by the backup controller to take control and it
works the same when the primary controller is back.


Unfortunately, if I try to do the same test while a job is running there are two different
behaviors depending on the initial scenario.

1st scenario:
Both the primary and backup controller are fine. I launch a batch script and I verify the script
is running with sinfo and squeue. While the script is still running I stop the service on the
primary controller with success but at this point everything gets crazy:

on the backup controller in the slurmctld service log I find the following errors:

slurmctld: error: Invalid RPC received REQUEST_JOB_INFO while in standby mode
slurmctld: error: Invalid RPC received REQUEST_PARTITION_INFO while in standby mode
slurmctld: error: Invalid RPC received REQUEST_JOB_INFO while in standby mode
slurmctld: error: Invalid RPC received REQUEST_PARTITION_INFO while in standby mode
slurmctld: error: slurm_accept_msg_conn poll: Bad address
slurmctld: error: slurm_accept_msg_conn poll: Bad address

and the commands sinfo and squeue are Unable to contact slurm controller (connect failure).

2nd scenario:
the primary controller is stopped and I launch a batch job while the backup controller
is the only one working. While the job is running, I restart the slurmctld service on the primary
controller. In this case the primary controller takes over immediately: everything is smooth
and safe and the sinfo and squeue commands continue to work perfectly.

What might be the problem?

Many thanks in advance!

Miriam